Lal Kitab and Traditional astrology & its relationship

Dear Jitin Ji,

Hare Rama Krsna,

//how did you came to the conclusion that “Lal Kitab belongs as a part to ancient Vedic Indian astrology†? //

Your query is still unclear,  that :

1) Do you want to say LK system is imported from foreign country, it is not from Indian\Vedic origin.

2) If it is not a part on various Astrological system generated in our vedic culture,  such as Nadis, Brighu , etc, why LK uses Niryana calculation while erecting the horoscope.
If it is the part of Western  \ Arabic system than Sayana horoscope should have been used, Rahu- Ketu should have been ignored.

3) Do you want to say that it is different from Parashari or its related system of astrology, we all agree on it that it depends on much more simplified principle as said in the Text Farman - 2, Lk-42 page 1 :
" sirf pakke ghar 12 akhir leti grah 9 se kismat bata deti ".
It does not adhere to additional complexities of Parashara system.
We cannot mix Parashara and LK at every instance. We have to see where Parashara principle is coherent with LK.
Still this system is not easy as many more additionals is also required to used LK system as whole as stated in the text :
"Fakt Rekha, Photo, ya Kote se kundli, janam-maiy chandra bana deti hai"

"फक्त रेखा , फोटो या कोठे से कुंडली , जनम -मय चन्द्र बना देती है."

Still my basic opinion is that initially we must keep distance with all other systems of horoscope analysis including Parashara to understand and grasp the finer points of LK.

****************

In some Nadis, like Bruhath Nadi,  even more simplified form is used, they do not consider 'Ascendant' and rely only on the fixed Karakatatwa of the planet, still there prediction are many times comes miraculous.

For example for profession they take Saturn, the causative planet for Karma, as the main planet.
By taking the position of saturn as well as its association with other causative planet or planets in 3,5,7,9,11 house position from Saturn, can give a clear picture about profession. No Ascendant required.

Just I want to say that this system also a sectoral form of Parashara \ Varahmihra system at large, and it not out of its principle.

*****************
After going through studies of various classic, respected G.K. Goel Sahab made the inference that this LK system could be much more older than Parashara \ Varahmihra system. May be these traditional system would have advanced later on.
 
I hope i have made the views very clear, still any doubts persist i will try to clarify my point.

Thanking you,
With Regards,
Vijay Goel
Jaipur.
www.LalKitabspeaks.com
www.IndiaAstroVedic.com